You're thinking about having sex for the first time and you're wondering (BTW, though you've probably heard horror stories from real girls and. We've asked real women to describe having sex for the first time. of those often awkward, sometimes painful, occasionally funny moments tend to stay with us. "I had been dating a guy on and off in college, from the time I was 19 to .. Instead he looked over and said, 'Damn girl, your shit's the bomb. Remember Natalie Dylan, the college girl auctioning off her virginity to pay for school or drugs or whatever? Well, shes got a going rate now.